Pricing Guide

*We base our prices off of Face to Face Games as they seem to be the most accurate and consistent on pricing for singles.

*If they are listed lower on Face to Face Games; Rares, Mythics and any Foils are priced at a minimum of $1.00; Commons and Uncommons are priced at a minimum of $0.50.

Buying Cards From Treasure Chest

  1. We check what the exact printing is listed at on Face to Face Games.

  2. If it is in stock on Face to Face Games we will take 20% off of their price. If it is labeled OUT OF STOCK on Face to Face, we will not take off the 20%. This is our price for the card.

  3. If the card is lower in quality, we will then take a percentage off based on how damaged. Lightly played takes off 10%, Played takes off 20%, and Heavily Played/Damaged takes off 50%

    *If a card is written in a language that isn’t English or Phyrexian, it is also marked down 50%

Selling Cards to Treasure Chest

  1. All of the pricing above also applies here

  2. After pricing above is applied, we then take a percentage based on if the customer wants Cash or Store Credit. For Store Credit we take off 30%, for Cash we take off 60%

    *We know this is a high percentage to take off for cash, unfortunately due to multiple break-in’s, we have had thieves come with our stolen cards to sell them back to us for cash. We applied this high percentage in attempt to mitigate this as much as possible. We apologize for the one ruining it for the many and thank you for your understanding.

    *All of the above is subject to change however we will be sure to update this section as well as announce any changes on our Facebook group.