ATTENTION: WE DO NOT BUY ANY OTHER TCG SINGLES, ONLY MAGIC THE GATHERING

Treasure Chest will buy MTG singles at a maximum value of $100 as listed on Face to Face Games. Anything higher in value is too much of a risk for the store should we not have any interested buyers.

*We do not buy any Commons or Uncommons unless valued at minimum $7.00 on Face to Face or in a collection. We will only look at Rares and Mythics otherwise.

*If you bring in any cards, we ask they be sorted alphabetically by set and alphabetically within the set, this saves us time looking through cards and gets it done faster for you. We will not look at your cards if they are not sorted like this.

*For more information please refer to our Terms of Service

Walk-ins

If you walk in with MTG singles hoping to sell them to the store we will take a maximum of 10 cards per person per day. Any more than 10 will be a Leave-in Store Trade. Please be aware that if we do have other customers in the store we may have to pause on your trade-in to help them grab product, check out, etc. So please be patient and courteous to staff and other customers.

Leave-in Store Trade

If you would like to trade in more than 10 cards it is considered a Leave-in Store Trade. With this sort of trade we will ask for your name and working phone number for you to leave your cards with us. Game stores can be busy so we may not have time to immediately go through your cards, leaving your cards with us ensures that we aren’t wasting your time as we try to go through your cards and help other customers. When you leave your cards with us we will ask you if you would prefer cash or store credit, we will prepare a total based on your answer. Once finished we will call you with the total and you are free to come in whenever convenient to pick up the cards we didn’t take and your pay/credit for what we did take. This process can be time consuming, especially with larger amounts of cards, so these kinds of trades can take up to a week or more. We ask for your patience until we have contacted you, before coming back in.

Collections

We are not currently taking in collections. Collections are 500 cards or more at one time. If you have a collection you would like to sell, please send us an email and consult with the owner Keith before bringing it in.

*All of the above is subject to change at any time the employee working sees fit, if an exception was made to any of the above guidelines in the past, do not expect it to be made again in the future.

Our pricing is slightly complicated so for our pricing guide please click here